Catskills Modern Amber Lake Cottage

Nomadomia Rating: 4.75 stars

• The Amber Lake Cottage is a beautiful and serene property perfect for relaxation and spending time with family and friends.
• The hosts are friendly and responsive, providing detailed instructions and recommendations for a comfortable stay.
• The property is well-maintained and clean, with modern furnishings and a fully equipped kitchen.
• Guests should be aware of some potential issues, such as the permanent RV/campsite and slippery rocks at the shore.
• Overall, the property is a great choice for those looking for a peaceful and comfortable getaway in the Catskills.

Good points:

• Beautiful and serene location with a stunning view of the lake.
• Well-maintained and clean property with modern furnishings and a fully equipped kitchen.
• Friendly and responsive hosts who provide detailed instructions and recommendations.
• Plenty of amenities, including a paddle boat, row boat, fire pit, and outdoor speakers.
• Perfect for relaxation, cooking, and spending time with family and friends.
• Close proximity to downtown Livingston Manor and Roscoe for grocery shopping and dining.
• Well-stocked home with everything needed for a comfortable stay.

Bad points:

• Some guests experienced issues with the property, such as a permanent RV/campsite adjacent to the house, lack of shade, and slippery rocks at the shore.
• One guest had a negative experience with the host, citing unresponsiveness and refusal to accept responsibility for the property's shortcomings.
• Some guests mentioned that the property could use some TLC, such as replacing burnt-out light bulbs and refinishing the deck.
• One guest experienced issues with the washer and dryer.

Time trend:

• The property has been well-maintained over the years, with many guests commenting on its cleanliness and modern furnishings.
• The hosts have made efforts to improve the property, such as adding new amenities and responding to guest feedback.
• Some issues, such as the permanent RV/campsite, have been present since the early days of the property's listing.